Lalor Offers Pro-Taxpayer Counter-Proposal to Cuomo Prison Education Plan


Assemblyman Kieran Michael Lalor (R,C,I-Fishkill) has announced a counter proposal to Governor Cuomo’s plan to offer free college classes to prisoners. Lalor is calling on the state to cut per prisoner spending by 10 percent. Once those savings are reached, the state would offer student loans to prisoners, not the free college courses Governor Cuomo is proposing.

“We have to cut recidivism rates, but we shouldn’t ask taxpayers to pay more and more to do it,” said Lalor. “Governor Cuomo seems to be saying we already spend $60,000 yearly per prisoner, what’s an extra $5,000 for his college plan. That’s the wrong attitude. We should be asking why we spend so much and how we can cut it. If we can cut it by 10 percent, we can look at offering student loans to prisoners. Because they’re not good credit risks, we’ll garnish a percentage of their wages to pay taxpayers back. But, this shouldn’t be a handout. Taxpayers can’t afford more handouts.”

Lalor continued, “If Governor Cuomo believes this is important, let’s cut spending per prisoner by 10 percent. That respects taxpayers who don’t want to pay for handouts for prisoners. It also allows New York to deal with recidivism. Cut spending by more than the cost of the college program and give some of that back to taxpayers. Then we’ll loan the money to the prisoners. The loan is important. It’s not a hand out, but a hand up. It teaches prisoners responsibility. It says they’re not just entitled to this, they have to work for it. That will do more to cut recidivism than any handout.”

“Throwing more and more money at a problem is never the answer,” Lalor added. “We can only offer this program if we can save tax dollars up front. Possible long-term savings aren’t enough. Let’s save the money right now. New Yorkers don’t like Governor Cuomo’s proposal. They’re rightfully outraged that Cuomo is asking them to pay even more in taxes to give a free degree to prisoners. If the governor is serious about cutting recidivism, he can do it, but he has to save tax dollars, right now, in the process. New Yorkers are willing to offer a second chance to prisoners. But we’re not going to pay more for it and the prisoners will have to work for it.”

Lalor’s legislation would require the state to cut per prisoner spending by 10 percent before the college program could begin. That 10 percent would be more than the cost of Governor Cuomo’s plan, delivering savings to taxpayers. The state would have to provide the courses in the most cost-effective manner possible, using online courses whenever possible.


Assemblyman Kieran Michael Lalor, a former teacher at Our Lady of Lourdes in Poughkeepsie, is a Marine Corps veteran of Operation Iraqi Freedom and a frequent guest on the Fox News Channel. Lalor is of counsel to the law firm Gaines, Novick, Ponzini, Cossu & Venditti. He is a graduate of John Jay High School, Providence College and Pace Law School and lives in Fishkill with his wife Mary Jo and their four young children Katie, Riley, Mikey and Kieran Jr..

You must be logged in to post a comment Login